In an ideal world the minutiae of chart compilation and the rules that determine what goes in and crucially where should be opaque to all. The Official UK Singles chart is the definitive list of what is most popular this week, and that’s the end of it.
But in truth, it was never like that, and if you have even half an interest in the medium then you will pay close attention to the precise way things are calculated - particular in this age of multiple formats and multiple means of content delivery. If you are reading these words you are the kind of person to whom this stuff matters. And the problem is this week the arcane world of chart rules ended up mattering to everyone.
The fate of Kate Bush’s Running Up That Hill track pivoted around a particular set of words, to be precise those contained in Rule 7.3(i), the first part of which reads (with my emphasis):
Automatic Reset – a track within the Top 100 on ACR and which is within 3 years of release can automatically return to SCR if it’s streams total increases by 25 percentage points greater than the streaming market change week on week.
Because this week the curious phenomenon of Kate Bush’s Running Up That Hill continued. It was the third most-purchased song of the week in online stores. It was far and away the most-streamed track of the week. Under any other circumstances it would have been the No.1 record of the week.
But because it is over 37 years since release (considerably more than 3) Rule 7.3 comes into play and it - in theory - is not eligible for a reset. And unlike in 2018 when Three Lions propelled itself from the depths of the back catalogue and back into public consciousness it just did not have the sales numbers to overcome that hurdle and top the charts anyway.
But who cares really, it is a footnote in writeups in the press, and surely only of interest to dedicated bloggers like myself who make a point of calling attention to these things.
But then respected trade journal Music Business Worldwide published a pointed editorial noting that for a single to be denied its true place at the top of the charts by a well-intentioned but suddenly awkwardly exposed rule was creating a huge credibility gap.